Kinetic Effects of β,γ-Modified Deoxynucleoside 5′-Triphosphate Analogues on RNA-Catalyzed Polymerization of DNA

A recently described DNA polymerase ribozyme, obtained by in vitro evolution, provides the opportunity to investigate mechanistic features of RNA catalysis using methods that previously had only been applied to DNA polymerase proteins. Insight can be gained into the transition state of the DNA polymerization reaction by studying the behavior of various β,γ-bridging substituted methylene (CXY; X, Y = H, halo, methyl) or imido (NH) dNTP analogues that differ with regard to the pK_a4 of the bisphosphonate or imidodiphosphate leaving group. The apparent rate constant (k_pol) of the polymerase ribozyme was determined for analogues of dGTP and dCTP that span a broad range of acidities for the leaving group, ranging from 7.8 for the CF₂-bisphosphonate to 11.6 for the CHCH₃-bisphosphonate. A Brønsted plot of log­(k_pol) versus pK_a4 of the leaving group demonstrates linear free energy relationships (LFERs) for dihalo-, monohalo-, and non-halogen-substituted analogues of the dNTPs, with negative slopes, as has been observed for DNA polymerase proteins. The unsubstituted dNTPs have a faster catalytic rate than would be predicted from consideration of the linear free energy relationship alone, presumably due to a relatively more favorable interaction of the β,γ-bridging oxygen within the active site. Although the DNA polymerase ribozyme is considerably slower than DNA polymerase proteins, it exhibits a similar LFER fingerprint, suggesting mechanistic commonality pertaining to the buildup of negative charge in the transition state, despite the very different chemical compositions of the two catalysts.