RNAi Modulation of Chlorogenic Acid and Lignin Deposition in Nicotiana tabacum and Insufficient Compensatory Metabolic Cross-Talk

Chlorogenic acid (CGA) and guaiacyl/syringyl (G/S) lignin formation involves hydroxycinnamoyl ester intermediacy, the latter formed via hydroxycinnamoyl CoA:shikimate hydroxy­cinnamoyl transferase (HCT) and hydroxycinnamoyl CoA:quinate hydroxycinnamoyl transferase (HQT) activities. HQT and HCT RNAi silencing of a commercial tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) K326 line was examined herein. NtHQT gene silencing gave relatively normal plant phenotypes, with CGA levels reduced (down to 1% of wild type) with no effects on lignin. RNAi NtHCT silencing had markedly adverse phenotypes (e.g., stunted, multiple stems, delayed flowering, with senescence delayed by several months). Lignin contents were partially lowered, with a small increase in cleavable p-hydroxyphenyl (H) monomers; those plants had no detectable CGA level differences relative to wild type. In vitro NtHCT kinetic parameters revealed preferential p-coumaroyl CoA and shikimate esterification, as compared to other structurally related potential acyl group donors and acceptors. In the presence of coenzyme A, NtHCT catalyzed the reverse reaction. Site-directed mutagenesis of NtHCT (His153Ala) abolished enzymatic activity. NtHQT, by comparison, catalyzed preferential conversion of p-coumaroyl CoA and quinic acid to form p-coumaroyl quinate, the presumed CGA precursor. In sum, metabolic pathways to CGA and lignins appear to be fully independent, and previous conflicting reports of substrate versatilities and metabolic cross-talk are resolved.