Impact of Ambient Vapors Present in an Electrospray Ionization Source on Gas-Phase Ion Structures

According to current consensus, structures of protomeric (or deprotomeric) tautomers of gaseous ions generated by electrospray ionization depend primarily on the nature of the spray solvent. To probe the effect of the spray solvent on protonation, 4-aminobenzoic acid (PABA) has often been selected as the model compound. It is widely accepted that the protonation in the gas phase takes place primarily on the carbonyl oxygen atom when the sample is sprayed in methanol and on the nitrogen atom when acetonitrile is used as the spray solvent. Although this observation is valid, our current results indicate that the determination of the predominant protomer in the gas phase by the spray solvent is an indirect effect moderated by the solvent vapor molecules present in the ambient ion source. To investigate real-time changes in protomer distributions due to solvents, we used ion-mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS). Initially, when a PABA solution in methanol was electrosprayed, the ion-mobility arrival-time profile recorded showed essentially one peak for the O-protomer. However, when acetonitrile or acetone vapors were introduced to the ambient-pressure ion source via the flowing desolvation gas, the intensity of the O-protomer peak diminished rapidly, and the N-protomer signal became dominant. The moment the acetonitrile (or acetone) vapors were removed from the ion source, the protomer-distribution signals began gradually reverting back to their original intensities. Furthermore, when PABA samples in methanol and acetonitrile were electrosprayed separately via a dual-sprayer setup, which allowed for the selective blocking of the gaseous ion-generation cascade of charged droplets from either sprayer, the predominant signal corresponded only to the N-protomer, irrespective of the position of the mechanical barrier. Because the mechanical barrier prevents only the gaseous ion formation, but not the physical access of solvent vapors to the ion source, it is evident that the solvent vapor that engulfs the ion source is the governing factor that decides the protomer distribution, not the nature of the spray solvent. Noticeably, acetonitrile wields a stronger effect on the manifested protomer distribution than many other solvents, including methanol, water, hexanes, and toluene. Apparently, the so-called “memory” of the solution-phase structures and the phenomenon described as “kinetic trapping” are both due to indirect effects caused by the solvent vapor engulfing the atmospheric-pressure ion source. Moreover, the so-called “memory” effect can either be “saved” or “erased” by exposing the initially formed gaseous ions to different solvent vapors from an alternative source.