Beyond Linear Elastic Modulus: Viscoelastic Models for Brain and Brain Mimetic Hydrogels
journal contributionposted on 23.04.2019, 00:00 authored by Mark A. Calhoun, Sarah A. Bentil, Eileen Elliott, Jose J. Otero, Jessica O. Winter, Rebecca B. Dupaix
With their high degree of specificity and investigator control, in vitro disease models provide a natural complement to in vivo models. Especially in organs such as the brain, where anatomical limitations make in vivo experiments challenging, in vitro models have been increasingly used to mimic disease pathology. However, brain mimetic models may not fully replicate the mechanical environment in vivo, which has been shown to influence a variety of cell behaviors. Specifically, many disease models consider only the linear elastic modulus of brain, which describes the stiffness of a material with the assumption that mechanical behavior is independent of loading rate. Here, we characterized porcine brain tissue using a modified stress relaxation test, and across a panel of viscoelastic models, showed that stiffness depends on loading rate. As such, the linear elastic modulus does not accurately reflect the viscoelastic properties of native brain. Among viscoelastic models, the Maxwell model was selected for further analysis because of its simplicity and excellent curve fit (R2 = 0.99 ± 0.0006). Thus, mechanical response of native brain and hydrogel mimetic models was analyzed using the Maxwell model and the linear elastic model to evaluate the effects of strain rate, time post mortem, region, tissue type (i.e., bulk brain vs white matter), and in brain mimetic models, hydrogel composition, on observed mechanical properties. In comparing the Maxwell and linear elastic models, linear elastic modulus is consistently lower than the Maxwell elastic modulus across all brain regions. Additionally, the Maxwell model is sensitive to changes in viscosity and small changes in elasticity, demonstrating improved fidelity. These findings demonstrate the insufficiency of linear elastic modulus as a primary mechanical characterization for brain mimetic materials and provide quantitative information toward the future design of materials that more closely mimic mechanical features of brain.