Iron(IV) Porphyrin Difluoride Does Not Exist: Implications for DFT Calculations on Heme Protein Reaction Pathways
journal contributionposted on 12.07.2005 by Abhik Ghosh, Peter R. Taylor
Any type of content formally published in an academic journal, usually following a peer-review process.
DFT (B3LYP as well as a number of common exchange-correlation functionals) predicts a low-spin Fe(IV) ground state for Fe(P)F2 (P = porphyrinato), whereas electrochemical evidence has apparently indicated an Fe(III) porphyrin π-cation radical formulation for such a species. Ab initio CASPT2 calculations favor a high-spin porphyrin π-cation radical as the ground state by a significant energetic margin, thus dramatically overturning the DFT results. In contrast, both DFT and CASPT2 calculations correctly indicate a true Mn(IV) ground state for Mn(P)F2. The remarkable failure of DFT to correctly predict the metal- versus ligand-oxidized nature of Fe(P)F2 may have significant ramifications for the theoretical modeling of heme protein reaction pathways where until now the performance of DFT has raised little concern.